Band Day Hall of Champions
Bold font denotes the first year the band made the Top 5 at Band Day.
| Year | Champion | Runner-Up | 3rd place | 4th place | 5th place |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1947 | A - Grant County Combined | ||||
| B - Rochester | |||||
| C - Francesville | |||||
| 1948 | Froebel (Gary) | Rochester | LaPaz | Pike Township (New Augusta) | Morton Memorial (Knightstown) |
| 1949 | Odon-Madison Township (Odon) | Froebel (Gary) | Morton Memorial (Knightstown) | Alexandria | Lebanon |
| 1950 | Alexandria | (tie) Hammond | Odon-Madison Township (Odon) | ||
| Morton Memorial (Knightstown) | |||||
| Pike Township (New Augusta) | |||||
| 1951 | Odon-Madison Township (Odon) | Lawrenceburg Consolidated | Huntington & Lancaster Townships (Huntington) | Morton Memorial (Knightstown) | (tie) Muncie Central |
| Portland | |||||
| 1952 | Noblesville | Lawrenceburg Consolidated | Morton Memorial (Knightstown) | Knightstown | Hammond |
| 1953 | Muncie Central | Knightstown | Jasper | Noblesville | Jeffersonville |
| 1954 | Jasper | Franklin | (tie) Muncie Central | (tie) Knightstown | (tie) Jeffersonville |
| Noblesville | Lawrenceburg Consolidated | Emmerich Manual (Indianapolis) | |||
| Lincoln (Vincennes) | |||||
| 1955 | Lincoln (Vincennes) | Franklin | Muncie Central | Jeffersonville | (tie) Anderson |
| Salem-Washington Township (Salem) | |||||
| 1956 | Franklin | Anderson | Princeton | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Lincoln (Vincennes) |
| 1957 | Anderson | Muncie Central | Franklin | Lincoln (Vincennes) | Emmerich Manual (Indianapolis) |
| 1958 | Anderson | Princeton | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Emmerich Manual (Indianapolis) | Jeffersonville |
| 1959 | Anderson | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Crown Point | Lincoln (Vincennes) | Zionsville |
| 1960 | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Anderson | Lincoln (Vincennes) | Crown Point | (tie) Madison Heights (Anderson) |
| Southport (Indianapolis) | |||||
| 1961 | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Crown Point | (tie) Highland (Anderson) | Selma | Wendell Willkie (Elwood) |
| Lincoln (Vincennes) | |||||
| Madison Heights (Anderson) | |||||
| 1962 | Lincoln (Vincennes) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Highland (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Anderson |
| 1963 | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Anderson | (tie) Highland (Anderson) | |
| Lincoln (Vincennes) | |||||
| 1964 | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Lincoln (Vincennes) | Anderson | Highland (Anderson) |
| 1965 | Crown Point | Richmond | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Lincoln (Vincennes) |
| 1966 | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Crown Point | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Anderson | Richmond |
| 1967 | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Highland (Anderson) | Wendell Willkie (Elwood) | Lincoln (Vincennes) |
| 1968 | Highland (Anderson) | Marion | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Anderson | Lincoln (Vincennes) |
| 1969 | Marion | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Highland (Anderson) | Richmond | Anderson |
| 1970 | Highland (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Richmond | Shenandoah (Middletown) | Wapahani (Selam) |
| 1971 | Highland (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Shenandoah (Middletown) | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) | Anderson |
| 1972 | Shenandoah (Middletown) | Wapahani (Selma) | Highland (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Martinsville |
| 1973 | Richmond | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) | Highland (Anderson) | Ben Davis (Indianapolis) | Chrysler (New Castle) |
| 1974 | Chrysler (New Castle) | Highland (Anderson) | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) | Richmond | Wapahani (Selma) |
| 1975 | Wapahani (Selma) | Carmel | Chrysler (New Castle) | Jasper | Greenwood Community |
| 1976 | Greenwood Community | Norwell (Ossian) | Carmel | Wapahani (Selma) | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) |
| 1977 | Norwell (Ossian) | Wapahani (Selma) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | East Noble (Kendallville) | Martinsville |
| 1978 | Wapahani (Selma) | Norwell (Ossian) | Anderson | Pike (Indianapolis) | Carmel |
| 1979 | Chrysler (New Castle) | Wapahani (Selma) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Anderson | East Noble (Kendallville) |
| 1980 | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Wapahani (Selma) | Norwell (Ossian) | Jay County (Portland) | Chrysler (New Castle) |
| 1981 | Wapahani (Selma) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Carmel | Jay County (Portland) | East Noble (Kendallville) |
| 1982 | Wapahani (Selma) | Madison Heights (Anderson) | Anderson | Jay County (Portland) | Richmond |
| 1983 | Wapahani (Selma) | Carmel | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) | Jay County (Portland) | Anderson |
| 1984 | Carmel | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) | Wapahani (Selma) | Muncie Southside | Edgewood (Elletsville) |
| 1985 | Anderson | Jay County (Portland) | Alexandria-Monroe (Alexandria) | Richmond | Southmont (Crawfordsville) |
| 1986 | Anderson | Richmond | Noblesville | Concord Community (Elkhart) | Southport (Indianapolis) |
| 1987 | Southport (Indianapolis) | Noblesville | Edgewood (Ellettsville) | Richmond | Anderson |
| 1988 | Richmond | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Southmont (Crawfordsville) | Edgewood (Ellettsville) | Martinsville |
| 1989 | Monroe Central (Parker City) | Jay County (Portland) | Martinsville | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Edgewood (Ellettsville) |
| 1990 | Monroe Central (Parker City) | Jay County (Portland) | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Concord Community (Elkhart) | Pike (Indianapolis) |
| 1991 | Monroe Central (Parker City) | Jay County (Portland) | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Delta (Muncie) | Martinsville |
| 1992 | Jay County (Portland) | Monroe Central (Indianapolis) | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Indian Creek (Trafalgar) | Northeastern (Fountain City) |
| 1993 | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Jay County (Portland) | Muncie Southside | Martinsville | Anderson |
| 1994 | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Jay County (Portland) | Winchester Community | Martinsville | Richmond |
| 1995 | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Winchester Community | Jay County (Portland) | Indian Creek (Trafalgar) | Martinsville |
| 1996 | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Winchester Community | Jay County (Portland) | Indian Creek (Trafalgar) | Martinsville |
| 1997 | Winchester Community | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Jay County (Portland) | Anderson | Indian Creek (Trafalgar) |
| 1998 | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Winchester Community | Jay County (Portland) | Anderson | Muncie Southside |
| 1999 | Franklin Central (Indianapolis) | Jay County (Portland) | Muncie Southside | Martinsville | Pike (Indianapolis) |
| 2000 | Muncie Southside | Jay County (Portland) | Martinsville | Centerville | Richmond |
| 2001 | Jay County (Portland) | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Pike (Indianapolis) | Centerville |
| 2002 | Muncie Southside | Jay County (Portland) | Pike (Indianapolis) | Richmond | Winchester Community |
| 2003 | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Jay County (Portland) | Centerville | Southmont (Crawfordsville) |
| 2004 | Muncie Southside | Highland (Anderson) | Jay County (Portland) | Centerville | Richmond |
| 2005 | Highland (Anderson) | Muncie Southside | Centerville | Jay County (Portland) | Southmont (Crawfordsville) |
| 2006 | Muncie Southside | Jay County (Portland) | Richmond | Highland (Anderson) | Centerville |
| 2007 | Highland (Anderson) | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Centerville | Jay County (Portland) |
| 2008 | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Highland (Anderson) | Northeastern (Fountain City) | Jay County (Portland) |
| 2009 | Highland (Anderson) | Muncie Southside | Northeastern (Fountain City) | Southmont (Crawfordsville) | Richmond |
| 2010 | Anderson | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Northeastern (Fountain City) | Jay County (Portland) |
| 2011 | Winchester Community | Richmond | Muncie Southside | Anderson | Jay County (Portland) |
| 2012 | Winchester Community | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Northeastern (Fountain City) | Centerville |
| 2013 | Winchester Community | Muncie Southside | Richmond | Anderson | Centerville |
| 2014 | Muncie Central | Winchester Community | Richmond | Anderson | Centerville |
| 2015 | Winchester Community | Northeastern (Fountain City) | Kokomo | Noblesville | Richmond |
| 2016 | Winchester Community | Kokomo | Jay County (Portland) | Anderson | Northeastern (Fountain City) |
| 2017 | Noblesville | Winchester Community | Jay County (Portland) | Kokomo | Anderson |
| 2018 | Noblesville | Anderson | Jay County (Portland) | Kokomo | Centerville |
| 2019 | Anderson | Kokomo | Jay County (Portland) | Centerville | Northeastern (Fountain City) |
| 2021 | Muncie Central | Centerville | Winchester Community | Jay County (Portland) | Kokomo |
| 2022 | Kokomo | Winchester Community | Muncie Central | Anderson | Centerville |
| 2023 | Kokomo | Muncie Central | Jay County (Portland) | Centerville | Anderson |
| 2024 | Muncie Central | Anderson | Kokomo | Richmond | Jay County (Portland) |